fantasy

Book Review: Beauty, by Robin McKinley

10th May 2009 By Julianne Leave a Comment

Beauty is a retelling of the story of ‘Beauty and the Beast’, in first person, from the point of view of Beauty. The storyline is pretty much the same as in the traditional story but some details are changed.

Beauty is a nickname, her real name is Honour but as a child she decided that she’d rather be called Beauty, and the name stuck. She does not, however, consider herself beautiful. Beauty likes riding horses and reading, and when her father’s business fails and one of her sisters marries, the whole family moves out of the town to start a new life in the countryside, and Beauty finds herself very capable at manual labour. Then news comes from town that one of the ships Beauty’s father owned may have returned, and he goes out to see if this is true. On the way home he becomes lost, and finds his way to the home of the beast.

This book does an excellent job of fleshing out the characters of ‘Beauty and the Beast’, making them more real. Beauty’s sisters are not ugly caricatures here, which I liked, and the magical castle in which the Beast lived was a fascinating place to see described.

This is probably the best-loved of Robin McKinley’s books, the first of her novels to be published, I was recommended it several times before I finally picked it up in a library sale. However, I preferred her more recent novel, Spindle’s End, which I read before Beauty (review coming soon). Most readers seem to think Beauty the better book, but I didn’t enjoy it as much. Beauty is an interesting but pretty passive heroine, and ‘Beauty and the Beast’ was never one of my favourite stories – it’s basically a romanticisation of Stockholm syndrome! The Beast in Beauty is just like the one in the original tale – he holds Beauty hostage in the hope that she will fall in love with him, and I just couldn’t see him as a hero. I also found Beauty to be too obsessed with the way she looks, and was disappointed that in the end she does become “beautiful” (which means taller and more mature looking), I would have preferred to see her get over it!

I think anyone who loves the story of ‘Beauty and the Beast’ will really enjoy this, but if you always found the plot of the original to be a bit thin, you won’t like it so much. This is a book aimed at children, I’d say pre-teens onwards would be best suited to it, but many adults have enjoyed it as well.

Book Review: Acorna’s Children: Second Wave, by Anne McCaffrey and Elizabeth Ann Scarborough

10th May 2009 By Julianne Leave a Comment

This book is the ninth book in the series begun with Anne McCaffrey and Margaret Ball’s “Acorna the Unicorn Girl” and the second in the continuation series, Acorna’s Children, following on from the original books centred around Acorna. The original Acorna books are a must-read if you are to completely understand the setting for these books, as very little background information is given in this novel, and events and characters from the previous stories are referred to frequently. You will also need to read the first in this series, “First Warning”.

In “Second Wave” the plague is no longer killing people but will start to attack in a new way. Khorii’s parents, Acorna Harakamian-Li and Aari, along with their friends Captain Jonas Becker, RK (Roadkill) the cat and Maak the android are in quarantine, still infected with the plague organisms which only Khorii can see. She sets off with her cat Khiindi, and her android brother Elviiz to try to find out how the plague works, but all does not go to plan, with interruptions from new friends, space pirates, Marl Fidd, and the arrival of Khorii’s twin sister, Ariinye or for short Ariin, who was stolen from Acorna’s womb before they were born.

And it all has something to do with Khiindi, who is clearly not just an ordinary Makahomian Temple Cat…

I would say that the characterisation is just as shallow in this book as in the others, and overall the characters are a bit too nice although some interesting people appear in this book – I wish they had been developed in more detail.

The plot gets more exciting yet complicated. It can be hard to keep track of what Khorii and her friends are meant to be doing as opposed to what they actually end up doing instead for a while every journey they take. This is why I give this book three stars rather than the four “First Warning” received from me.

I would recommend “Second Wave” and the rest of this series for mid-teenagers most as the principal characters are around that age themselves. The ending of this book is left open for the story to be concluded in the third and last novel in the Acorna’s Children series, “Third Watch”.

fantasy

Footer